SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Latest SOTDs will be posted here.

Moderators: Murali Venkatraman, Saravanan

SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby bb » Tue Sep 27, 2005 10:44 pm

Song of the Day: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan.

http://www.dhool.com/sotd2/691.html

- Saravanan writes:

We have had songs from movies dubbed from Hindi, in SOTD earlier too- Lata’s songs from vanaratham here: http://www.dhool.com/sotd2/273.html and Jikki’s songs from avan here: http://www.dhool.com/sotd2/492.html

Today let us listen to a song from another such dubbed venture: Mehboob Khan’s Aan (1952/ Mehboob Productions)

* * * *

Image

Mehboob Khan’s was a typical rag to riches to story. His real name was Rajmal Khan. Gaining valuable experience during his early years in Imperial Film Company and later in Sagar Movietone, his first directorial venture was Judgement of Allah (1935). He followed it up with landmark movies like Manmohan (1936), Jagirdaar (1937), Ek Hi Rasta (1939), Aurat (1940), Bahen (1941) and Roti (1942). He then started making films under his own banner- Mehboob Productions. With Anmol Ghadi (1946) began Mehboob’s historic association with Naushad. Starring Surendra, Suraiyya and Noorjehan, the film was famous for its songs. Mehboob’s next noteworthy effort was the unforgettable classic Andaaz (1949), which brought together Raj Kapoor, Dilip Kumar and Nargis.

* * * *

Andaaz was followed by the magnificent Aan (1952)

Image

And though Aan was not such a thumping success as Mehboob’s next classic Mother India was; it still remains among his masterpieces. This time Mehboob Khan surpassed himself in the sheer grandeur of his canvas. Aan is enshrined in the history of Indian cinema as India’s first ever full-length Technicolour movie. Indeed, it was a remarkable achievement in its time- for the film was shot on 16 mm, then blown up to 35 mm and converted to technicolour in London.

Image

Picking an engrossing story of adventure and romance written by R.S.Choudhury, Mehboob got S.Ali Raza to come up with some scintillating dialogues. Imaginative cinematography by Faredoon A. Irani, crisp editing by Shamsudeen Khadri, breathtaking art direction by M.R Achrekar and D.R.Jadhav, thrilling stunts conceived by Azeem- Douglas, spellbinding choreography by Krishnakumar- Suryakumar and dazzling costumes designed by Fazal Din- Chagan Jivan- Alla Ditta were all valuable embellishments that added to the splendour of the movie.

Image

The story had all the right ingredients for a successful costume drama. Jai Tilak (Dilip Kumar) is a brave peasant, and Mala (Nimmi) the village belle madly in love with him. The haughty princess Rajshree (Nadira) is the third corner of the triangle. The benign Maharaja (Murad) disappears suddenly, apparently gone abroad for medical treatment. The cruel prince Shamsher (Premnath) takes over the reigns. His tyranny waves in an air of oppression and unrest; and when he attempts to molest Mangala leading to her death, Jai rises in revolt. He kidnaps Rajshri, and in the process of the taming of the shrew, both fall in love with each other. The dramatic rescue of the old Maharaja and the nail-biting duel between Jai and Samsher form a fitting finale to the proceedings.

Image

This film heralded a complete change in image for Dilip Kumar, who had hitherto been identified with tragic, morose roles. I even remember reading somewhere that donning those roles repeatedly had affected him so much that he took on this refreshing role under psychiatric advice! And as the dashing Jai, he was a revelation. Glamorous Nadira, with a perpetually arched eyebrow, was perfectly cast as the imperious Rajshree. Pretty Nimmi and the stylish Premnath completed the perfect ensemble. Cuckoo, Mukri, Sheela Naik and Amir Bano were the others in the cast.

Image

The extravagant opulence of the sets, the spectacular visuals and the universal appeal of good triumphing over evil propelled Aan to elicit notice even beyond Indian frontiers. Edited to 129 minutes, it was released all over Europe, titled ‘Mangala, the Rose of India’. The enchanting epic prompted Cecil B. Demille write to Mehboob Khan, “I found it an important piece of work, not only because I enjoyed it but also because it shows the tremendous potential of Indian motion pictures for securing world markets. I believe it is quite possible to make pictures in your great country which will be understood and enjoyed by all nations and without sacrificing the culture and customs of India. We look forward to the day when you will be regular contributors to our screen fare with many fine stories bringing the romance and magic of India.”

* * * *

The outstanding feature of Aan, of course, was Naushad’s wonderful music score. Dilip Kumar and Naushad shared a rare rapport, and many of the thespian’s movies were music marvels, thanks to the painstaking efforts of Naushad. Paying glowing tributes to Dilip Kumar, Naushad says “My association with Dilip Kumar sprang essentially from the fact that this thespian brought the same dedication to his craft as I did to my art..”

Image

Naushad reminisces on Dilips Kumar’s reaction to the songs of Aan, “I remember him complaining to me at the time of Andaz and Aan that I composed excellent songs for the heroines but made him sing simple strains like, Toote na dil toote na, toote na... and Maan mera ehsan are nadaan -- ke maine tujh se kiya hai pyaar. And I’d assure him it was not so, that these songs were equally good. On the subsequent success and popularity of the songs he’d say, "You were right, Naushad Saab."

Speaking of Aan, Naushad says “I created a symphony for Aan on stage with a hundred musicians. I had a special tent... made of blankets... on the surface, I laid out coir carpets, so that the sound wouldn't echo. The final recording was done in London. We worked day in and day out for three months. We were under enormous pressure when we received news that the Liberty cinema in Bombay would open with this film. People slept for days outside the theatre to book tickets in advance. My symphony was widely appreciated in Britain, it was played on BBC. Orson Welles who was busy with his Othello also happened to see the rushes of Aan and loved the music.”

Lyrics were by Shakeel Badayuni. The songs were:

Aaj mere man mein sakhi- Lata Mangeshkar & Chorus
Aag lagi tanman mein- Shamshad Begum
Dil mein chhupa ke- Mohd. Rafi
Gao tarane man ke- Mohd. Rafi, Sahmshad & Lata
Khelo rang hamare sang- Shamshad & Lata
Maan mera ehsan- Mohd. Rafi
Main rani hoon raja ki- Shamshad Begum
Mohabbat choome jinke haath - Mohd. Rafi
Takra gaya tumse dil hi to hai- Mohd. Rafi
Tujhe kho diya humne- Lata Mangeshkar


Eight of these vintage delights can be listened to here: http://www.musicindiaonline.com/l/17/s/movie_name.167/

* * * *

Not satisfied with releasing the film in Hindi, Mehboob Khan got it dubbed in Tamil as well. The Tamil version, also titled Aan, had dialogues written by B.S.Ramiah and lyrics penned by the indefatigable Kambadasan. I have heard from several old-timers that the Tamil songs were greatly popular in their time, and were aired ever so often by Radio Ceylon. I have never heard these songs on radio and was naturally eager to lay my hands on them. After a dogged search for many years, I got all the 10 songs from an audio store in Bhavani, near Erode. The Tamil equivalents of the aforementioned Hindi originals were:

indRu endhan nenjil sakhi
aa sududhE en manamE
manathil mei kaathal
paadu singara paadalai
nagaru nagaru mel jal jal
yEtRiduvaai aruL thaan
naan raaNiyE rajavin
mOhamuththam tharum
saNdai mooNdathuvE
izhandhEn unai anbE


Going by the lyrics, Kambadasan seems to have been asked to strike as close to the Shakeel Badayuni’s muse as feasible. And in order to match the lip movements in the close-up shots, the Tamil lines and syntax seem to go haywire in places. To add to this, Lata and Shamshad Begum have themselves sung the Tamil versions of their Hindi songs! Rafi doesn’t seem to have joined this southern sojourn though; the old record sleeve proclaimed the male singer to be S.M. Sarkar. Wonder who this singer was; his Tamil isn’t good at all, and his baritone too is a far cry from the honeyed voice of Rafi. Incidentally ‘mOhamuththam tharum maan thaLirkaiyaaL’ was the inspiration for V-R’s latter day ‘senthamizh thEn mozhiyaaL’.

Mehboob Khan must have got the ‘not-so-positive’ feedback from Kambadasan and other Tamils involved in the dubbing process, for he made some hasty amends. He got M.S.Rajeswari to sing the Lata solos and Soolamngalam Rajalakshmi to sing the Shamshad ones! Thus the record had 14 songs in all.

* * * *

Shamshad Begum was born in Amritsar and started her singing career when AIR Lahore commenced broadcasting. She learned music from the legendary Ustad Hussain Bakshwale Sahab. Music Director Gulam Haider was impressed with her, and made her sing for his films in the early 40s. In 1944, Shamshad sang ‘Naina bhar aayE neer’ for the movie Humayun, and she became a celebrity overnight, for such was the popularity she attained with that single song! Shamshad Begum had arrived……

At a time when stalwarts like Noorjehan, Surayya, Amirbai Karnataki, Uma Devi (later to be christened Tun Tun and pursue the career of a comedienne) and Zohrabai Ambalewali were at their prime, Shamshad, with her unique nasal tones, managed to carve a unique niche for herself.

Image

Shamshad Begum acquired the status of a singing icon even before Lata and Asha made their debut. Music Directors would wait for her dates to complete their recording. Naushad, C.Ramachandra, O.P.Nayyar, Shankar-Jaikishen, Ram Ganguly, S.D.Burman and Khemchand Prakash gave her such immortal songs like ‘ badal aaya jhoom ke’ (Shahjahan), ‘ Darti ko aakaash pukare’ and ‘Taqdeer bani bankar bigdi’ (Mela), 'Duniya me ghareebon ko aaram nahi milta' (Zamindaar), 'Armanon ki basti me hum aag laga baithe' (Shirin Farhad), ‘Ye duniya dil ki chor’ (Shabnam), 'Dil thandi hawa me' (Shama), ‘Chandni aayi ban ke pyar’ (Dulari), 'Mere piya gaye Rangoon' (Patanga), ‘Kaahe koyal shor machaaye’ (Aag), ‘Thandi sadak ki’ and ‘Roop ki dushman’ (Jadoo),’ ek do teen’ (Awara), 'Milte hi aankhen' and ‘Chod babul ka ghar’ (Babul), 'Saiyyan dil me aana re' (Bahaar), 'Boojh mera kya naam re' (C.I.D), 'Kabhi aar kabhi paar' (Aar Paar), 'Maine dekhi jag ki ree.' (Sunehre Din), ‘Humdard ka afsana’ (Dard), 'Kahin pe nigahen kahin pe nishana.' (C.I.D), 'Pee ke ghar aaj' (Mother India)……

Listeners of the current generation are familiar with the name of Shamshad Begum too, thanks to the remixes galore of her old classics. Not a day goes by when I don’t happen to listen to the remixed 'Saiyyan dil me aana re' or 'Kabhi aar kabhi paar' on the local radio stations here.

Listen to Shamshad Begum sing ‘naan raaNiyE rajavin’ from aan

I tried to get a link to the Hindi original ‘Main rani hoon raja ki’, but it doesn’t seem to be available anywhere. All I got was a link to a sample clip of the song here:

http://www.hamaracd.com/hcdindia/asp/Di ... ue=&Page=6

* * * *

And here is Soolamangalam Rajalakshmi singing the same song

More on this exceptional artiste here: http://www.dhool.com/sotd2/386.html

Rajalakshmi was born in 1940; hence she would have been just 12 years old when she sang this song!

Image

So listen on to these forgotten songs from a bygone era…
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby bb » Tue Sep 27, 2005 10:47 pm

Not a day goes by when I don’t happen to listen to the remixed 'Saiyyan dil me aana re' or 'Kabhi aar kabhi paar' on the local radio stations here.


'kabhi aar kabhi paar' is pretty famous here in US as well.


Soolamangalam Rajalakshmi's voice doesn't resemble a 12 year old at all. Was she really that young when she sang this song?
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby vengayam » Wed Sep 28, 2005 12:02 am

kabi aar kabi paar wasn't it by Geeta Dutt?
vengayam
Match Referee
 
Posts: 252
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 11:46 pm
Location: thaayagam

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby OISG » Wed Sep 28, 2005 12:48 am

Naushad is a phenomenon. (Though his image got a dent after Rev.Jerry Amaldev's comments).

Certainly a rare one from the bygone era.Shamsad's voice is superb. So was Soolamangalam's. I do have an anti-hindi fixaation but I loved the Shamsad version.

Hindi singers never made any attmepts to give due respect to the regional language songs they sang.But the sweetness of Shamsad's voice makes you forget about the C++ code written by Kambadasan in the garb of lip-synch lyrics.Thoroughly enjoyed both the versions.

Soolamangalm and her voice had a generation gap. but she sounds equally good in this tamizh version.

Dilip Kumar :lol: It must have been casting coup akin to casting AVM Rajan in the lead role in the remake of Chaplin's movies.
OISG
Silly Point
 
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:45 am

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby raja m » Wed Sep 28, 2005 5:26 am

As usual one more detailed look at a time slice of a byegone era from Saravanan the historian.

I happened to watch Mother India for the first time when it was shown as part of the Indian movie series on AMC TV - imo the movie even though was not as gripping as I thought it would be, was grand , very indian in its basics and grand as any of the Hollywood classics of that period. I never knew that such movies were dubbed in tamil..

Thanks for transporting movie buffs like me to time periods that many have forgotten.
raja m
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby bb » Wed Sep 28, 2005 6:50 am

Please inform Saravanan that Shamshad Begum is very much alive. I don't have his address off-hand to write him directly.

Thanks and Regards,
Sreenivas
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Wed Sep 28, 2005 7:39 am

The thing I remember about AAn is a reviewer's comment(actually got published in a foreign magazine):
"It just goes Aan and Aan and Aan..."
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Wed Sep 28, 2005 12:03 pm

Thanks Saravanan for the Aan details, hearing Shamshad's voice after a long time.

If possible can u please provide details on Kambadasan who also wrote the Akhbar songs

Bala
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby bb » Wed Sep 28, 2005 12:37 pm

Bala, you can read more on Kambadasan here: http://www.dhool.com/sotd2/273.html
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Anniyan » Wed Sep 28, 2005 10:58 pm

OISG,
What were Jerry Amaldev's comments on Naushad? I would like to know.
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Wed Sep 28, 2005 11:06 pm

Dear Saravanan,
Naan Raniyae song enaku netrum work agavillai.Indrum work agavillai.Pl hlep me!
With Love,
Usha Sankar.
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby bb » Wed Sep 28, 2005 11:14 pm

I just checked and both song links work. Do you have real player?
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Saravanan » Wed Sep 28, 2005 11:49 pm

Usha Sankar, I too am able to listen to the songs. Please try once again.

Anniyan, OISG was referring to an interview where Jerry Amaldev had spoken of his apprenticeship under Naushad. I had given the link to the interview when we featured Amaldev's 'en kaNmaNi' here:

http://www.dhool.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=2427

Btw, Anniyan, have you seen the Tamil Aan? Has it been screened at Vintage Heritage? Or as a rule you don't screen dubbed movies? I would like to know how these dubbed movies (Aan, Vanratham, Avan, Akbar..) were received by the Tamil audience, and whether they had a decent run. I know, of course, that the songs became popular.
Saravanan
The wind in the willows
 
Posts: 599
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:08 am

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Anniyan » Thu Sep 29, 2005 3:27 am

Saravanan,
I have not seen Aan and Vintage Heritage has not screened Aan so far for want of print. Any good old film will be screened in VH and VH screens dubbed films also. Informed circle in VH confirms that the dubbed films viz. Aan, Akbar, Vanaratham and Avan were all enjoyed by Tamil audiences that time mainly for their music and had a decent run also. VH also screens other language films and this month they screened the memorable telugu film Swarga seema with P Bhanumathy and Nagaiah in the lead which had mesmerising music by Ramachandra Rao and Nagaiah. PB took the audience to dizzy heights when her Paavuramma song appeared on the screen. The film was thoroughly enjoyable.

I was baffled by the remarks of Amaldev on such a giant MD Naushad.He should have understood that all MDs had their limitations and their creativity comes to the fore only in composing melodies. The expression that he felt cheated is amusing. Are you listening OISG?
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Thu Sep 29, 2005 5:22 am

Dear bb and Saravanan,
Ennidam real player iruku.Unga site la irukum ella songsum work aradhu.Indha thread layum ella songs um work aradhu.Anal indha Naan RAaniyae song matum work agalai.Try panninal ovvoru timeum same boxae newva open aradhu.Anal song open agalai.
With Love,
Usha Sankar.
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby _Da VInci » Thu Sep 29, 2005 5:34 pm

I couldn't hear the song too. There is no .rm file. THere is only a html file where the song file should be and it repeatedly opens up the same page !
_Da VInci
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest.Ramesh.p » Thu Sep 29, 2005 9:49 pm

After a while, though, I felt cheated," said the short, bearded music director. "Naushad was my ideal then, I thought he'd do everything connected with the song. Instead, all he did was to compose the raw melody. Embellishments and arrangements would be done by various other musicians who handled the different sections like brass, strings and others. I was even more disillusioned when I realised it was people like me, kept in the shadows; who'd write many of the tunes, and Naushad would just pick from them."

I think ridiculous comment about genius like NAUSHAD. We just read from this article about how NAUSHAD conducted in symphony and recording in London. I think he had chose wrong person as assistant irrespective of talent he has.
ramesh
Guest.Ramesh.p
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest.Ramesh.p » Thu Sep 29, 2005 9:53 pm

My earlier post refers to Music director Jerry comment about NAUSHAD.
Rmesh
Guest.Ramesh.p
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Thu Sep 29, 2005 10:06 pm

Well, Naushad is a giant, no doubt. But if he did only part of the music-making work and left a lot to his assistants, it is unfair, IMO, to hail him as a genius non-pareil. We had MD's lile Salilda, who innovated in tune, melody and orchestration.

Compare the current scenario - Anu Malik does basic tunes, and leaves the rest to his 'Asistants'. AR Rahman designs the whole song himself. Who would you call a genius? It is a no-brainer , really. Now, dont come back saying it is blasphemy comparing Anu and Naushad - this is just a comparion of the scenario not of the persons involved.

No one questions what Naushad was capable of - but if he lazily allowed his assistants to do the job and took credit for it, then he does deserve brickbats.

As a process, if all a MD is expected to do is provide raw melodies and the rest can be taken care of by professionals, then what individulaity does the MD provide.

Also, this explains why it is difficult to differentiate, say, a Naushad Melody from a CR melody. The professionals have filled in the blanks.

The difference between good and great, IMO, is that the great can be unequivocally credited for their art, from conception to execution.

Like they say, it takes a great team to perform a symphony excellently(and the conductor duly takes primary credit even though the team has performed) but no team has ever produced a excellent symphony .
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Thu Sep 29, 2005 10:09 pm

" was even more disillusioned when I realised it was people like me, kept in the shadows; who'd write many of the tunes, and Naushad would just pick from them." "

This clearly shows that Jerry actually wrote tunes then passed off as Naushad's. Does this not mean that Naushad actually took credit for someone else's melody, contrary to Anni's interpretation that "Naush always did melodies and only left orchestration to assistants".

If we question that and say that Naushad never took credit for other people's melodies, we are questioning the honesty of a Reverend, mind.

rajsrini
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Anniyan » Thu Sep 29, 2005 11:02 pm

Even the talented MD R Govardhanam (and sometimes even MSV?) was kept in the shadows during IR's peak period. In such a scenario where is this Amaldev. Even the pre-IR period is only the same.

Who said ARR does the songs himself? Really not. He has got a set of some worthless people around to do these things. The end product is the result.
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby bb » Thu Sep 29, 2005 11:10 pm

I couldn't hear the song too. There is no .rm file. THere is only a html file where the song file should be and it repeatedly opens up the same page !


You are not clicking at the correct link. The links to the songs are further below, in the writeup, under "Listen to Shamshad Begum sing ‘naan raaNiyE rajavin’ from aan" and "And here is Soolamangalam Rajalakshmi singing the same song".
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Fri Sep 30, 2005 3:27 am

Anniyan Sir

You wrote
"Who said ARR does the songs himself? Really not. He has got a set of some worthless people around to do these things. The end product is the result.".

I hope this is a sarcastic remark. If not, why would the people who contribute to the 'End result" be considered "worthless"?

Bala
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Fri Sep 30, 2005 3:38 am

anniyan
If RG or any of the assistants IR has really had CREATIVE inputs into his output, why dont they say so. As recently as TiS, we had his long-time assistants like Viji etc saying that "Every note that you hear of IR's music is his"

To explain this, one has to go into the difference between Conducting and orchestrating, which are fundamentally different. Better people than me have produced better documentation, which I am sure bb has tucked in somewhere in this forum or tfmpage. AFAIK, RG and others conducted for IR during the period you are talking about - thats not the same as giving composition inputs.
Fact remains that(and you can check with your musical circles) the only MD's with the reputation of being responsible for every note, every sound that goes out of their baton or Salilda, IR and ARR and to a large extent, MSV.

Infact, VS Narasimhan, a highly talented composer himself, was with IR for a long time. I never saw him even hint remotely about giving creative inputs to IR.

ARR, too, has assistants that do a lot of dirty work for him but to date, none of them dare claim that they had creative inputs into his work.

Salilda ofcourse was Salilda. The fountainhead of all complete composers in India.

idhellaam ungaloda sandai podanumno, ungalai argument-la jaikkanumno naan sollalai. These are widely accepted facts, including in this forum. Someone like Srikanth D can throw more light on this.

Ultimately, you wil believe what you will.

I wonder if you believe that RG or VSN or Viji Manuel or Devendran or Dhina(yes Dhina was with IR at some point) wrote the tune for IR's songs. Even a die-hard IR hater would cringe if such a comment was made.
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Guest » Fri Sep 30, 2005 7:06 am

//Aan, had dialogues written by B.S.Ramiah //

Just to add my 'rendu salli'

B.S.Ramiah was the editor of 'MaNikkodi', a literary journal in Tamil that has since achieved a cult status. Tamil literary historians refer to the 40s during which the journal was published as 'Manikodi era' as it was a milestone period for modern Tamil literature.

Poet Vaitheswaran (incidentally he is turning 70 this week and we are felicitating him this Sunday - 2nd Oct - in Chennai) told us that for the dubbing of Aan, B.S.Ramiah had to air dash to London quite a few times. As such, in the (un)recorded history of Tamil literature, he should be the second Tamil author to be a frequent flier, albeit for a short period . The first place is always reserved for the great A.K.Chettiar, editor of Kumari Malar and the producer - director of the unique documentary on Mahatma Gandhi.

anputan,
era.murukan
Guest
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby _Da Vinci » Fri Sep 30, 2005 2:40 pm

Oops, thank you BB. It was a little deceptive for the hyperlink was showing up clearly and since it also could make one look one for the song elsewhere by its wordings.

A beautiful song. Thank You Saravanan. The recording was crystal clear too. Just as the Lata Mangeskar song in Vaanaradham I couldn't follow the lyrics, despite being sung by a Tamil playback singer.
_Da Vinci
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby OISG » Fri Sep 30, 2005 9:12 pm

Jerry's comments- I could not get over for many days. Truth?untruth?comments of a frustrated musician? .....etc.. but the picture i have painted for myself on Naushad did get some black paint. My pointer was not to delink the primary discussion. sorry about that.

Anniyan,I do not want to comment on Assistant's contribution in an MD's work here. :D
OISG
Silly Point
 
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:45 am

Re: re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Anniyan » Fri Sep 30, 2005 10:44 pm

ARR, too, has assistants that do a lot of dirty work for him but to date, none of them dare claim that they had creative inputs into his work.

Dear guest (edhavadhu oru paerai vachukkoppa),

The assistants do not dare claim that they had supplied d creative inputs lest they would lose their lucrative jobs, don't you understand?
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Lokesh. » Fri Sep 30, 2005 11:35 pm

"The thing I remember about AAn is a reviewer's comment(actually got published in a foreign magazine):
"It just goes Aan and Aan and Aan..." "

Guest, very entertaining stuff indeed.
The commentator must be a typical American, with typical acidic American wit, and even more typical American pronuncation.
Lokesh.
 

re: SOTD #691: naan raaNiyE rajavin from Aan

Postby Anniyan » Sun Oct 02, 2005 9:25 pm

Dear Era. Murugan,
What is that you are doing in Chennai? You are running any association? Pl elaborate.
Anbudan Anniyan.
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

Next

Return to Song Of The Day

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron