SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Latest SOTDs will be posted here.

Moderators: Murali Venkatraman, Saravanan

SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby bb » Sun Apr 03, 2005 9:38 pm

Song of the Day: en kaNmaNi en paadal kELadi from ninaivO oru paRavai.

http://www.dhool.com/sotd2/609.html

- Saravanan writes:

Sung by SPB. Lyrics by Vairamuthu. Music by Jerry Amaldev.

* * * *

Image

I am not bound to win, but I am bound to be true. I am not bound to succeed, but I am bound to live by the light that I have.

- Abraham Lincoln


I don’t understand the lyrics wholly, yet each time I listen to the tender strains of ‘Aayiram kannumaai kaathirunnu ninne njaan’, I am overcome at the fragility and fleeting ethereality of human relationships that the song manages so effortlessly to convey across barriers of language. Is it the studied leisurely gait of the song, or the magic of Yesudas, or the dreamy interludes, or the insistent choral refrain ‘painkili malar thenkili’, or the invigorating effect of the combined concoction- I cannot fathom. Yet the song leaves me shaken at every listen, and I offer a mental salute to the composer who crafted such a jewel.

And even within my limited knowledge of Malayalam film songs, many of this composer’s creations rank high in my list of favorites- the caressing gentleness of ‘Kannodu kannoram ni kani malaralle’ and ‘Aalorungi arangorungi aayiram therorungi’ (Ente Maamatti Kuttiyammaku), the fun and frolic that reverberates throughout ‘Minnum minna minni’ and the hushed angst in ‘Thilangum thingale’ (No.1 Snehatheeram Bangalore North), the stylish prelude with which ‘Neerkili neendhivaa’ (Punnaram Cholli Cholli) opens, the silky warp and waft of ‘Dhevadhumdhubhi saandralayam’ (Ennennum Kannettante), the euphoric empathy at the determined streak of adolescent mutiny that ‘Vanambaadi edho theerangal thedunna vanambaadi’ (Deshadanakili Karayarilla ) evidences…. Scintillating signatures of an unsung genius.

Luck has always played a capricious game of hide and seek with Jerry Amaldev. The man studied for years in a seminary with the intention of becoming a priest, but realizing his true calling, gave up his religious aspirations without much regret. His inherent gift for music, and years of learning Hindustani classical, tabla and the piano made him approach the legendary Naushad. Deeply impressed at the young lad’s enthusiasm, Naushad took him on as his assistant. After 5 years, Jerry went to US and completed a Bachelors degree in Music in New Orleans, followed by a Masters in Composition at Cornell University, Ithaca, New York. He even taught in Queen’s College in New York, before returning to India to try his hand at film music.

He could not have wished for a better opening. Manjil Virinja Pookkal (1980/ Navodaya) by Faazil, starring Shankar, Mohanlal and Poornima Jairam was a thumping success, aided strongly by Jerry’s brilliant score. The awesome interludes in SJ’s ‘mizhiyoram’ were of a kind never heard before. The State Award was his, and he looked all set to be mfm’s darling of the decade. But things didn’t turn out quite that way, and despite coming out with stunners in the ensuing years, Jerry Amaldev found himself slowly, but surely sidelined.

1986. Jerry Amaldev was approached to compose music for a Tamil film, and he set about the task, excited at the prospects that this album could summon up. ninaivO oru paRavai (Scorpio Creations) was produced by K.Ajit and directed by ‘uchchakattam’ fame N.S.Rajbharath. Rahman was the hero. Vairamuthu wrote the lyrics for the songs.

And what wonderful songs they were! ‘thEn kudiththa thendRal’ (SPB/Chitra) must be the among the softest romantic duets ever. ‘endhan kaNNE’ (KJY/BSS) is made for the mellifluosness of KJY. ‘muththam engE’ tantalizes despite the innate limitations of S.P.Shailaja. 'kaathalikka katRukkoL’ might have made Raj Seetharaman really famous, if only the song had ever been aired.

And as for the SOTD, do I really need to dwell upon it? Vairamuthu writes with his pen darting as cupid’s arrow, Jerry Amaldev conceives a tune that casts a beguiling spell, and our SPB takes charge nonchalantly to make Amaldev’s Tamil debut unforgettable.

I imagine Rahman singing in a cloudy night, perhaps under the window of his beloved (a la Gemini in ‘kaadhal nilavE kaNmaNi radha’) trying to get her to sleep. The overcast sky opens up, and the sudden showers, instead of cooling his ardor, end up kindling the flame of passion! And then do you suppose, sleep would ever beckon the eyelids of one whose heart bursts with longings wrought by love, and whose ears thrill to the passionate wooing of her suitor? Yet he sings his lullaby, and when she does sleep exhaustedly in the end, her eyelids would surely be heavily laden with delicious dreams.

Jerry Amaldev’s famed orchestrational brilliance is evident in the flowing interludes- they urge the listener to try flapping imaginary wings and soar exultantly high in the air. I have seldom listened to operatic passages of this class in tfm! SPB must have sensed the extraordinary beauty of the composition, for he unleashes his magic in all its potent strength, and gleefully cloaks each line with his endearing nuances.

How much Jerry Amaldev must have looked forward to this album! Read this interview at the time of the expected release of ninaivO oru paRavai (December 1986) here:

http://www.studio-systems.com/Playback& ... /Dec30.htm

Unfortunately for him, ninavO oru paRavai was never released. But Radio Ceylon did air the songs, at least for a brief while in 1986-87. And then the songs disappeared forever. Much later, (yes, in Virudunagar!) I chanced upon a record of the film (with Rahman on a bike featured on its sleeve), and got those cherished songs recorded.

poovE iLam poovE (1987/ Vijayakala Pictures) did manage a release, but was a prompt failure, notwithstanding the then successful pairing of Suresh and Nadia. Despite this, Jerry Amaldev’s songs therein like ‘paattu paada vandhEn’ (VJ), ‘gangai nadhi’ (SJ) and ‘puththam pudhidhu’ (SPB/Chitra) did get a deservedly generous airtime.

I don’t know if Jerry Amaldev scored for a Tamil film ever again. (The vandhadhu vasantham mentioned in the interview seems to have shared the stillborn fate of ninaivO oru paRavai)

Offers and Awards have come sporadically. He was awarded the Amritavarshini Puraskaram for music in the Sangeetha Nataka Akademi Awards 2001. In the year in which Ilaiyaraja won the Kerala State Govt’s Award for the Best Music Director (song) for Kaalapani, Jerry Amaldev bagged the Award for the Best Music Director (Background music) for his work in Kazhakam.

Jerry Amaldev leads a quiet, contended life in Selaiyur, a Chennai suburb. He does music for Christian devotional songs. He harbors no bitter thoughts, and accepts his fate with a philosophical shrug.

When asked about Amaldev (Sangeetha Sagaram/Asianet), Vani Jairam spoke glowingly about his “beautiful orchestrations”. She ended her panegyric saying ‘Oh, he’s a very nice man”. And that perhaps is an ultimate tribute to this neglected composer!
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Udhaya » Sun Apr 03, 2005 10:38 pm

Saravanan,

Great find again. I've heard "mizhiyOram" many times, but had no idea about this Amaldev. It's sickening that such a talent has remained hidden all these years from TFM. The SOTD gives me a hint on reasons why he might not have made it. The interludes don't follow any conventions of other musicians. The tune is complex and not readily accessible. If the song can't be hummed by a commoner or at least whistled by a fan, odds are it won't be a hit. With all this, I'm not saying he should've succumbed to the established ways, but rather I wish he had success after success to have defeated our expectations for how long interludes should last and pry us from predicting where the charanam will begin or end. Too bad for us, his niceness is his only reward. But then again, would I really want today's half-wit heroes dictating to Amaldev where the beat should fall in a song?

Anyway, please give such extinguished voices a second coming at least in the confines of dhooL. Our stable may be small, but we love and cherish every castaway miracle that comes our way.
Last edited by Udhaya on Wed Apr 06, 2005 11:37 am, edited 1 time in total.
Udhaya
Scribe
 
Posts: 367
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2004 3:20 pm
Location: a vast imaginary recess

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby rajsrini » Sun Apr 03, 2005 10:40 pm

Intersting part of the interview is his comments regarding Naushad.
For a man variously regarded as a maestro and a giant, it seems like he was no more than a Anu Malik Act I. Difficult to believe but difficult to refute given Jerry's priestly background as well.
I have always found it difficult to differentiate between old hindi songs in terms of composer's style except for Salil Chaudhary and to an extent, Madan Mohan and Shankar-Jaikishen. Maybe, this is a reason!

Saravanan, do you have any further information on this? Though not TFM-related, it would be interesting to compare and contrast the SI and NI Music industries. Clearly, we could always differentiate MSV, KVM just by hearing the song which shows the involvement of these men in all aspects of film-music making. NI industry doesnt seem to have a glorious tradition in this regard.
OISG? Any Comments?
rajsrini
Spectator
 
Posts: 86
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 7:50 pm
Location: India

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby rajsrini » Sun Apr 03, 2005 10:58 pm

Intersting part of the interview is his comments regarding Naushad.
For a man variously regarded as a maestro and a giant, it seems like he was no more than a Anu Malik Act I. Difficult to believe but difficult to refute given Jerry's priestly background as well.
I have always found it difficult to differentiate between old hindi songs in terms of composer's style except for Salil Chaudhary and to an extent, Madan Mohan and Shankar-Jaikishen. Maybe, this is a reason!

Saravanan, do you have any further information on this? Though not TFM-related, it would be interesting to compare and contrast the SI and NI Music industries. Clearly, we could always differentiate MSV, KVM just by hearing the song which shows the involvement of these men in all aspects of film-music making. NI industry doesnt seem to have a glorious tradition in this regard.
OISG? Any Comments?
rajsrini
Spectator
 
Posts: 86
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 7:50 pm
Location: India

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Guest » Mon Apr 04, 2005 7:50 am

Great choice sara.
Guest
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby _Da Vinci » Tue Apr 05, 2005 5:53 am

Saravanan,

That was a very unusual but a very beautiful song.

I remember having a read few online articles on Jerry Amaldev after I came to know that ‘Manjil Virinja Pookal’ was from him and that he broke the trend of formulaic music in Malayalam films. What a haunting song, Janaki’s version of ‘Miziyoram’was! I saw the film just because of this song and I still remember how wonderfully it blended with Poornima Jeyaraman walking in the mist.

Everything is unusual in this song. The interludes have a heavy western classical bent but they still don’t stand separate from the song. Amaldev must have been very courageous to have tried a song like that in his first attempt at Tamil Film music, for he should have known he was taking a big risk !

Please continue bringing out such songs, pal…
_Da Vinci
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby OISG » Tue Apr 05, 2005 11:36 am

Harmony wooing melody ......zapped.

I have listened to Brahms some time back.JA does have a Brahms influence,when most of the film composers always built on Bach,Mozart,Haydn or even Grieg's musical thoughts whenever WCM was the requirement. But this is a complete departure from known Indian Film music patterns.Just Brilliant... and who else other than SPB could have partnered JA!

Thanks for this extraordinary song.

JA 's comments on Naushad was a shock.iswaro rakshadthu!

rajsrini ,ennayum oru portuttaga ninaithu....thanks. I felt SDB and even Kalyanji-Anandji had their style.RDB initially patented the jazzy,heavy beat,rhymish pattern tunes but post Sholay-1973 all was lost in the din.LP,Bappi,Rajesh Roshan all started sounding similar.But the worst was to come in 90s when Nikhil-Vinay tried to sound like Nadeem-Shravan....case of Keith Atherton tring to imitiate Ken Rutherford's batting.

KVM-sorry! GR had his style,V-R had theirs but KVM had "mosther" :?
OISG
Silly Point
 
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:45 am

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Guest » Tue Apr 05, 2005 9:47 pm

OISG, "keith arthurton trying to imitate Ken Rutherford's batting" - idhai thaan naan edhirpaarthaen!.
I love these sort of similes from you
Guest
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Guest » Tue Apr 05, 2005 11:13 pm

"LP,Bappi,Rajesh Roshan all started sounding similar."

Come on, OISG. L-P and sounding like BL and RR!! :o
No way. L-P from the late 60s to 1988 were a class apart, and above the rest.

Lokesh
Guest
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Da Vinci » Wed Apr 06, 2005 5:00 am

On second thoughts, I can see why Jerry Amaldev failed.

Ilayaraja and ARR became mainstay because they brought in a necessary change that was not too alien to the general taste of the audience at the same time. Ilayaraja's roots are in the folk music, despite whatever he learned from Western Classical, and ARR was clever enough (or probably not a master enough in Western Classical) not to stray too far, but Jerry Amaldev, as I can see from this song, tried to break entirely the convention (or probably unable to synthesize it to the light music tradition). I would like to hear from Malayalam film song enthusiasts as to how much and in what manner his songs were unconventional and if they had any relation to his failure there.
Da Vinci
Fifty, waves bat at pavilion
 
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 2:58 pm

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Udhaya » Wed Apr 06, 2005 11:38 am

Just had a weird doubt. This Jerry didn't morph later as part of the duo, Phil-Jerry for "Thottaachinungi" did he?
Udhaya
Scribe
 
Posts: 367
Joined: Tue Oct 26, 2004 3:20 pm
Location: a vast imaginary recess

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Saravanan » Wed Apr 06, 2005 8:52 pm

Thanks for the responses, guys! I really glad you too enjoyed the song and (re)discovered the genius of Jerry Amaldev.

rajsrini, that observation on Naushad disturbed me too. I had held him very high :(

Udhaya, I agree with you- this is not a song that can be easily sung or even hummed. Perhaps that led to its disappearing from even Radio Ceylon after a brief outing.

Da Vinci, you are probably right. Perhaps Amaldev wasn't flexible enough!
Saravanan
The wind in the willows
 
Posts: 599
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:08 am

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby thops » Sat Apr 09, 2005 2:42 pm

i have to admit that i have not listened to such a remarkable song in a long time...a rare combination of minimalism and grandioseness - an oxymoronic composition...puthiya isai kathavuthanil nuzhainthathamma...sevi unaraa isaiyaiyai manam unarnthathamma...thanks a lot saravanan...
thops
Non-striker
 
Posts: 24
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 9:23 pm
Location: Durham, NC, USA.

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby anon aka rajaG » Mon Apr 11, 2005 7:01 am

From rajaG-

My 2 cents:

1. For a long time I thought this song was composed by Ilayaraja (until a friend of mine corrected me). The violins and flute in the interlude and the ascending progressions in the first interlude are very IR like. The reason for my stating this is that if IR's songs could have been a hit, then there was no reason that this song could not be - just plain bad luck that it turned out to be so.

2. The main melody is very hummable (I don't agree with Udhaya here). In fact, with the swing beat, it is a lot like Pukartha Chala hun Main (Mere Sanam).

It is unfortunate that such a fantastic talent never got the due recognition.
anon aka rajaG
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby R KUMARAN » Wed Apr 13, 2005 12:35 am

Thanks for letting this song come flowing like honey into our souls through our ears, after nearly two decades.
R KUMARAN
Into double digits
 
Posts: 18
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2005 10:54 pm
Location: Madurai, When not in Delhi or When not Travelling

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby R KUMARAN » Wed Apr 13, 2005 12:42 am

Just like we have Malarndhum Malaraadhavai, we could also have another topic, perhaps naming it (in the same way as Radio Ceylon) "Athi Pookal". Under this we can post those songs that were rarely heard even in the best of times when other songs from those films had their field days. For example 'Nellum Neerum Onrai Ondru Purindhu Kollanum' SPB and SPS(?) from the film 'Manaivi Uruvagiral', music by SG.
R KUMARAN
Into double digits
 
Posts: 18
Joined: Thu Mar 24, 2005 10:54 pm
Location: Madurai, When not in Delhi or When not Travelling

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby abrahamT » Mon May 02, 2005 11:04 pm

Excellent findings about Jerry Amaldev.
Will you be able to publish his other tamil songs too?
I tried a lot, but it seems those songs are not available in the market and Internet.
abrahamT
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Lokesh » Tue May 03, 2005 9:46 pm

Sara,

Just one question.
When will you re-start V Kumar series?

It was the sole reason why I joined dhool.com.
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby lokesh. » Tue May 10, 2005 10:29 pm

Saravanan?????
lokesh.
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Guest » Tue May 10, 2005 10:57 pm

Abraham
Two songs of Jerry amaldev each from (song: Then Kuditha) Ninaovo Oru Paravai and (song: Putham pudhiyathu) Poove Ilam Poove is availabe with coolgoose.com. Use the search option to downlaod the songs.
Guest
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby Sugrutha » Sun Jun 25, 2006 1:46 pm

What an exquisitively delicate composition ! It is a tragedy that this man is living in our own backyard and no one is utilising his talents. The loss is entirely ours, we listeners'.
Sugrutha
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby KRISHNAN K » Wed Aug 09, 2006 7:24 pm

The writeup as well as the views were more interesting than the song itself. The song was similar to a modern art painting lacking the usual form or structure. It might be due lack of knowledge/rasanai. I am not sure if there is touch of a genious in it but this stuff surely did not have the "yogithai" to comment adversely on the works of the "magician of music" ( Naushad). May be here a vessel not totally empty has made most sound.
KRISHNAN K
 

re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby KRISHNAN K » Wed Aug 09, 2006 7:26 pm

Sorry I was referring to my lack of knowledge/rasanai.
KRISHNAN K
 



re: SOTD #609: en kaNmaNi en paadal from ninaivO oru paravai

Postby mythila » Fri Aug 11, 2006 12:24 am

It is SPB again all the way :)
There is no percussion for most part of the song except few guitar strokes here and there. Nice violin interludes.
mythila
Well Set, Batting On
 
Posts: 82
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 12:05 am
Location: bangalore


Return to Song Of The Day

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest