SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Latest SOTDs will be posted here.

Moderators: Murali Venkatraman, Saravanan

SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby bb » Wed Dec 05, 2007 12:14 am

Song of the Day: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

http://www.dhool.com/sotd2/912.html

- Saravanan writes:

The Nightingale in God’s Own Country- Part IV

Image

After years of composing music for stage plays of all the major theatre troupes in Kerala, the immensely talented M.K. Arjunan composed music for the movie ‘karutha pournami’ (1968) starring Madhu, Saradha and Vijayanirmala, and Janaki accorded the debutant a warm welcome by singing three of his compositions for the movie- the two solos ‘kavithayil mungi’ and ‘manathin muttathu’, and the duet with Yesudas, ‘sisuvine pOl’. The next year saw Janaki and Jayachandran serving that unforgettable concoction in Kaapi, ‘yamunE prEma yamunE …yadukula rathidEvan evidE evidE…’ for K.P. Kottakkara’s movie ‘Rest House’. The same movie also had a haunting Janaki solo, ‘vasanthamE variyEriyoo’. ‘kasithetti poovinoru’ (raktha pushpam/1970), ‘pranaya sarOvaramE’ (CID Nazeer/1971), ‘thulavarsha mEghangaL’ (anvEshanam/1972) were songs sung by Janaki for Arjunan that fetched both the singer and the composer accolades. 1973 saw Janaki singing songs of diverse delights in numerous albums of Arjunan such as ‘panchavadi’, ‘padmavyooham’, ajnathavasam’, ‘Ragging’ and ‘pachanOttukkaL’. ‘poo nilaavE vaa’, the lullaby that Janaki rendered in the 1975 movie ‘padmaragam’ would find place among Arjunan’s best compositions. Having sung in the movie ‘kayamkulam kochunni’ in 1966, Janaki now sang in the movie ‘kayamkulam kochunniyudE makan’ in 1976, and the song ‘swapnangaL thazhikakudam’ was quite popular in its time. In the following years, Arjunan formed a winning partnership with Vani Jairam and many of his wonderful compositions went to the accomplished Vani. Nonetheless, Arjunan did set aside some delectable treats for Janaki such as ‘thaarunya pushpavanathil thaLirththallO paarijaatham’ with Jayachandran (madhuraswapnam/1977), ‘maavu pooththu’ (kaathirunna nimisham/1978), ‘pramada vanathail’ (irumbazhikaL/1979), ‘saptha parapanjam’ (karipuraNda jeevithangaL/1980), ‘ee raavil nintE kaamukiyavam’ (oothikaacchiya ponnu/1981), ‘kaayal karayil’ (kayam/1982), ‘thudakkam’ (manassoru mahasamudram/1983) …

* * * *

Guarded with fierce possessiveness by TFM, M.S. Viswanathan had little time to venture into other languages, including his mother tongue. Nevertheless, his limited forays in Malayalam fetched him unlimited fame. MSV might not have been too generous to Janaki in Tamil, but in Malayalam she was sought repeatedly by the Mellisai Mannar to bring to life his enticing compositions. ‘aa nimishathintE nirvridiyil naan’ from the movie 'chandrakantham' (1974, scripted and directed by Sreekumaran Thampi) is one such spellbinding semi-classical number that the master crafted in two versions, one by Yesudas and the other in the Janaki’s dulcet tones. ‘jeevikkaan maRannupOya sthree’ (1974) starring Soman, Mohan, Sheela and Kanchana, based on a famous novel by Vettoor Raman Nair and directed by K.S. Sethumadhavan is a movie all but forgotten, except for its songs written by Vayalar and set to tune by MSV, foremost among which are the two versions, one by Yesudas and the other by Janaki of ‘veeNa poovE’.

Listen to ‘veeNa poovE’ from jeevikkaan maRannupOya sthree (1974) Image
Sung by S. Janaki
Lyrics by Vayalar
Music by M.S.Viswanthan


malineethadamE’ is another marvel crafted by MSV and sung by Janaki for the same movie. ‘aval oru thodarkathai’ was dubbed into Malayalam, and Janaki repeated her magic in ‘kaNNilE’. Yesudas and Janaki got to render two duets, ‘manasoru swapnakhani’ and ‘chanchalitha’ for MSV in the Prem Nazeer- Jayabharathi starrer ‘dharmakshEtrE kurukshEtrE’ (1975). Janaki sang two haunting solos ‘nisheedhini nisheedhini’ and ‘pOkam namakku’ under MSV’s baton in Sheela’s supernatural thriller ‘yakshagaanam’ (1976); Janaki would haunt the Tamil populace with ‘venmghamE’ set in the same tune as ‘nisheedhini’ in the Tamil remake ‘aayiram jenmangaL’ two years later. ‘aavaNi poorna’ with Jayachandran (kuttavum sikshayum/1976), ‘vasanthamE nee vannu’ (hrudayamE saakshi/1977), ‘manasaoru thaamarapoika’ (akshayapaathram/1977), ‘sarathkaala chandrika’ (etha oru manushyan/1978), ‘mukilugaLE’ (velluviLi/1978), ‘janmam thEdiyathenthinu seetha’ (sundarimaarudE swapnangaL/1978) are some songs that linger in memory in this partnership. In the movie raNdiloNNu (1978), MSV sang an alluring duet with Janaki, ‘panchavan kaattilE’. vaadaka veedu, pathivritha, maNi kOya kuRuppu (all 1979), Lorry, swargadEvatha, thirakal ezhuthiya kavitha- the dubbed version of marO charitra, (all 1980), kOLiLakkam (1981) are albums wherein Janaki sang some of the master’s scintillating compositions.

Image

Based on a story by Vijayan Karottu, Bharathan’s 1982 classic ‘marmaram’ starring Nedumudi Venu and Jalaja had music by MSV and the master extracted from Janaki some outstanding songs; while her ‘vattathil vattaram’, and ‘Om..iruLin thuyilunarum manthiram’ zoomed to the top of the popularity charts, it is the heavenly Hindolam delight ‘karNaamrutham kaNNanu’ that makes me sigh in ecstasy. When MSV beckons with rapturous plucking on the strings of the veena, Janaki cannot but respond with a rousing rendition…

Listen to ‘karNaamrutham kaNNanu’ from marmaram (1982) Image
Sung by S. Janaki
Lyrics by Kavalam Narayana Panicker
Music by M.S. Viswanathan


Not content with his largesse of giving her 3 solos in ‘marmaram’, the master also crafted for the same movie a mellifluous Janaki- Unni Menon duet, ‘angam prathi anangam’. In the waning years of his illustrious career, MSV summoned Janaki repeatedly for his Malayalam ventures such as kaikEyi (1983), minimOL vathikkaanil, athiraathiram, thennal thedunna poovu (all 1984), priyamvadakkoru praNayageetham, bhagavaan (both 1986) and ammE bhagavathi (1987). Even as late as 1990, Janaki sang ‘chalanam jwalanam’ for MSV in Bhadran’s story of a misunderstood clairvoyant ‘Iyer The Great’ starring Mamootty, Shobhana and Geetha.

Listen to ‘chalanam jwalanam’ from Iyer The Great (1990) Image
Sung by S. Janaki
Lyrics by Poovachal Khader
Music by M.S. Viswanathan


* * * *

Shankar-Ganesh were greatly in demand in TFM, throughout the 70s and the first half of the 80s. And it must have been the immense goodwill that they enjoyed with filmmakers that landed them with some opportunities to compose music for movies other languages, especially Kannada and Malayalam. A quick look at few of their works in Malayalam reveals that S-G gave Janaki some memorable souvenirs to cherish from their repertoire therein. Thoppil Bhasi’s 1974 movie ‘chakravaakam’ starring Prem Nazeer and Sujatha had Janaki singing the enticing ‘makayiram nakshatiram’ for S-G. ‘arama dEvathamaarE’ from the 1979 movie ‘prabhu’ is another winner that S-G presented in Janaki’s vocals. ‘Love in Singapore’ (1980) had two Jayachandran-Janaki duets, ‘thaalalayam’ and ‘nyaan raja’ tuned by S-G that find place regularly in TV and radio programs featuring listeners’ requests. The Prem Nazeer- Rani Padmini starrer ‘sangarsham’ (1981) had Janaki singing two duets in S-G’s music- one with Yesudas, ‘thoomanjil mungi’ and one with Jayachandran, ‘kaNdu kaNdarinju’. ‘ee raavil nyaan’ from the Kamalahasan starrer ‘maattuvin chattangaLE’ (1982) and ‘pala pooththu’ from A. Vincent’s ‘pournami raavil’ (1985) are other songs from the SJ/S-G collaboration that linger on in memory.

* * * *

During his years under the tutelage of G.K. Venkatesh, Ilaiyaraja had witnessed firsthand the astute comprehension skills, remarkable range and versatility of Janaki. Janaki was GKV’s favorite singer and Ilaiyaraja had always found his interactions with Janaki highly enriching, for she was totally devoid of airs and delivered the desired nuances with disarming ease. During those years, IR was playing the guitar and combo-organ regularly for many Malayalam composers as well, and observed the high regard that even revered stalwarts like Dakshinamoorthi Swami held for Janaki. During the recording sessions with Swami, IR had opportunities aplenty to observe the effortlessness with which Janaki got the intricacies of Swami’s compositions right and the wholesome praise that came from the venerable Guru.

Image

Janaki too found a kindred soul in IR, for even as an assistant, IR had impressed her with the meticulous manner in which he would explain to her the notes and nuances. The rapport that developed thus between IR and Janaki paved the way for a magnificent alliance when IR arrived with ‘annakkiLi’, the album that rewrote history. For when IR arrived, with exhilarating ideas, inventive structures, intricate arrangements, a determination to stray away from the beaten track and a fierce will to succeed, Janaki was there waiting for him… ready to translate his thoughts to action… he was the muse… she was the voice…

Those momentous years saw IR reserving his choicest creations for Janaki, and the singer struck gold every time she brought alive with iridescent hues IR’s captivating canvas. And over the decades, Janaki has quite understandably remained the singer to have rendered the most number of IR’s compositions.

Ilaiyaraja’s tryst with Malayalam cinema has been truly memorable, and given his avowed fascination for Janaki’s voice and a rightful trust in her capabilities, it was but natural that the Isaignani summoned his prima donna to render some of his finest compositions in Malayalam. Malayalam moviegoers first got a tantalizing taste of a slice of the IR magic when Devaraj- Mohan’s 1976 Tamil movie ‘uRavaadum nenjam’ was dubbed in Malayalam in 1978 as ‘aaRu maNikkoor’. The famed SPB- Janaki duet ‘oru naaL unnOdu oru naaL’ was rewritten in Malayalam by Mankombu Gopalakrishnan, and this time Janaki teamed up with Yesudas to render ‘oru naaL ullasa thirunaaL’.

Listen to ‘oru naaL ullasa thirunaaL’ from aaRu maNikkoor (1978) Image
Sung by Yesudas & Janaki
Lyrics by Mankombu Gopalakrishnan
Music by Ilaiyaraja


In the same year, K.G. George called upon Ilaiyaraja to compose music for his movie ‘vyamOham’. Starring Adoor Bhasi, Mohan and Lakshmi, the movie was a remake of Sridhar’s ‘pOlicekaaran magaL’. The album has Janaki singing the dainty ‘poovadikalil’ (solo version and duet version with Yesudas), and ‘neeyO nyaanO’ with Jayachandran. Replete with the early orchestral wonders of IR, the songs are keepsakes of an alluring era of film music.

Listen to ‘poovadikalil’ from vyamOham (1978) Image
Sung by Yesudas & Janaki
Lyrics by Dr. Pavithran
Music by Ilaiyaraja


Would Janaki have been reminded of the delightful 'indha mandRathil Odi varum' that she had sung 16 years back in the Tamil original? For in this Malayalam equivalent, Ilaiyaraja had crafted a pallavi that bore a resemblance, albeit infinitesimal, to Viswanathan- Ramamoorthi's tune in 'pOlicekaaran magaL'.

‘paalaruvi paadivaru’ from dhooram arikE (1980) is another early IR-Janaki delight. panneer pushpangaL found its way to Malayalam as panineer pookkaL (1981), and Janaki sang ‘poonthaLir aadi’ with Yesudas. Another IR album that is monopolized by Janaki is ‘garjanam’ (1984), dubbed from Rajnikant’s ‘garjanai’. The year 1982 holds an exalted place in the chronicle of the IR-Janaki partnership; two albums that were sheer magic came out that year… One was ‘aalOlam’ starring K.R. Vijaya, Gopi and Nedumudi Venu. Janaki had two beautiful solos in ‘aalOlam’- ‘thanal virikkan kuda nivarthum’ and ‘veeNe veenE’ on which four years later IR would build his ‘oNNaa reNdaa thaamarappoo’ (thazhuvaatha kaigaL).

Listen to ‘veeNE veeNE’ from aalOlam (1982) Image
Sung by S. Janaki
Lyrics by Kavalam Narayana Panicker
Music by Ilaiyaraja


The other album of 1982 that I am referring to is, of course, OlangaL. Balumahendra roped in Amol Palekar, Poornima Jairam and Ambika for his take on Erich Segal’s ‘Man, Woman and Child’, and for this ‘OlangaL’, Ilaiyaraja went to town with the immortal tune ‘thumbi vaa’. And who else but Janaki could perceive the scintillating vistas envisaged by the maestro and render that aural extravaganza! IR was so besotted by the tune that he reused it in other languages as well, with Janaki rendering them again and again, and yet again. I have a colleague from Kerala here who has retained this tune as his mobile ring tone, and every time he receives a call, all my carefully drawn up work schedules go haywire, for I soar to a faraway world of enchantment where time seems to stand still and the mere thought of work would seem blasphemous...

Listen to ‘thumbi vaa’ from OlangaL (1982) Image
Sung by S. Janaki
Lyrics by O.N.V. Kurup
Music by Ilaiyaraja


vezhambal kElum vEnal kudeeram’ is another treasure that the album stores, this one by Yesudas supported superbly by Janaki’s humming. ‘aa raathri’ (1983) directed by Joshi, with Mammootty, Rathish and Poornima Jairam in its cast is another memorable IR album. Whilst the Yesudas- Janaki duet ‘ee neelima than charuthaiyil’ is certainly pleasing, it was the Janaki solo ‘kiLiyE kiLiyE’ that found repeated airtime. ‘manjaLum kuLirum’ with Krishnachandran (sandhyakku virinja poovu/1983) and ‘priyanE uyir neeyE’ with Yesudas (pin nilaavu/1983) are two dazzling duets that defy the ravages of time. K. Vishwanath’s grand musical ‘saagara sangamam’ was dubbed in Tamil as ‘salangai oli’, while it retained its original name for the Malayalam version. Janaki was the mainstay of IR’s wonderful album in all the languages. If in ‘mounamaan nEram’, Janaki was wooed by SPB, in ‘mounam pOlum madhuram’ it is the tender timber of Jayachandran that pleads to Janaki for succor.

Listen to ‘mounam pOlum madhuram’ from saagara sangamam (1983) Image
Sung by Jayachandran & S. Janaki
Lyrics by Sreekumaran Thampi
Music by Ilaiyaraja


Balumahendra returned to Malayalam cinema with a remake of his Kannada movie ‘kOkila. Titled ‘oomakkuyil’, this movie had Y.G. Mahendran, Aruna and Poornima Jairam essaying the lead roles. ‘thaazhampoothali nin’ (Janaki), ‘OrmagaLE koode varoo’ (Yesudas & Janaki) and ‘kaattE kaattE’ (Jayachandran, Krishnachandran & Janaki) were songs crafted by IR that were heard all day long. The 1984 movie ‘onnanu nammal’ starring Mammootty, Mohanlal, Seema and Poornima Jairam had two duets, ‘kalkkandam chundil’ and ‘vaalittezhuthiya’ by Yesudas and Janaki that showcased IR’s renowned orchestral brilliance.

Appachan’s Navodaya came out with the enterprising 3D movie ‘My Dear Kuttichathan’ in 1984. Directed by Jijo and having the child actors Suresh, Sonia and Arvind in the lead, the movie was a splendid success and was dubbed into several other languages as well. I still remember watching it as a school kid agog with curiosity, and the hugely entertaining movie was all a child could ask for and more… If Ilaiyaraja’s awesome BGM was the talk of the town, his songs were no less… Janaki and Shailaja delighted us with their ‘aalippazham perukkaan’… Interestingly, IR had the Tamil version ‘chinna kuzhandhaigaLE’ sung by Vani Jairam and Sujatha.

Listen to ‘aalippazham perukkaan’ from My Dear Kuttichathan (1984) Image
Sung by S. Janaki & S.P. Shailaja
Lyrics by Bichu Thirumala
Music by Ilaiyaraja


Fresh from his directorial debut with the Kannada movie ‘pallavi anupallavi’, Mani Ratnam ventured into Malayalam cinema in 1984 with a bold look at the trade union movement. Titled ‘unaroo’, the movie starred Mohanlal, Sukumaran, Ratish, Deepa and Satyakala. Janaki sang the enthralling ‘theeram thEdi Olam paadi', which IR structured on his own ‘rOja ondRu muththam kEtkkum’ (kombErimookkan). The other song ‘deepamE’ is a boisterous joyride with Janaki making merry with Krishnachandran and Anto. Balumahendra made his third sojourn with ‘yaathra’ (1985) with Mammootty and Shobhana, and here again IR saves for Janaki the feet-tapping delight ‘yamunE ninnudE nenjil’

Listen to ‘yamunE ninnudE’ from yaathra (1985) Image
Sung by S. Janaki & chorus
Lyrics by O.N.V. Kurup
Music by Ilaiyaraja


Director Bhadran came out with ‘poomukhapadiyil ninnEyum kaththu’ starring Mammootty, Mohanlal, Rehman, Sulakshana and Srividya in 1986. Music was by IR; Janaki and Yesudas sang the haunting ‘konchi karayallE’…

Listen to ‘konchi karayallE’ from poomukhapadiyil ninnEyum kaththu (1986) Image
Sung by Yesudas & S. Janaki
Lyrics by Bichu Thirumala
Music by Ilaiyaraja


The other song ‘poonkkaatinOdum kiLikaLOdum’ is again a soothing Yesudas caress, with Janaki chipping in with a bewitching humming…

Listen to ‘poonkkaatinOdum’ from poomukhapadiyil ninnEyum kaththu (1986) Image
Sung by Yesudas & S. Janaki
Lyrics by Bichu Thirumala
Music by Ilaiyaraja


After a break of 6 years, IR and Janaki got together in Malayalam again in 1992 with Faazil’s ‘pappayudE swantham appoos'. Mammootty, Shobhana, Master Badshah and Suresh Gopi were in the cast. As in the case of each work of IR for Faazil, the movie had some exceptional songs, with two of them coming Janaki’s way. Even while portraying grief, Janaki is statuesque and stately in the poignant lullaby ‘en poovE pon poovE’.

Listen to ‘en poovE pon poovE’ from pappayudE swantham appoos (1992) Image
Sung by S. Janaki
Lyrics by Bichu Thirumala
Music by Ilaiyaraja


The other Janaki solo from the album is the one that assumed the halo of an anthem for a while… such was its popularity… ‘Olathumbathilum ooyalaadum chellapayinkiLi’ the heartwarming visuals of a mother’s frolicsome capers to amuse her little son … she gives the child a bath, feeds him, plays with him, prays for his long life and health, dreams of the grand triumphs that await him…. Janaki bubbles with the rapture and warmth of motherhood… The album also has Yesudas singing another version of the song. The movie was dubbed in Tamil as ‘poovE pon poovE’, and the Tamil equivalent of the song is ‘sOlaipoondhendRalil oonjaladum chella painkiLi’ .

Listen to ‘Olathumbathilum’ from pappayudE swantham appoos (1992) Image
Sung by S. Janaki
Lyrics by Bichu Thirumala
Music by Ilaiyaraja


Except for the dubbed versions of Kamal's 'magaLir mattum' which was released in Malayalam as 'Ladies Only' (1994) and Raghevendra Rao's 1990 Telugu hit 'Jagadeka Veerudu Athiloka Sundari' which was belatedly released in Malayalam as 'Hi Sundari' in 1995, Ilaiyaraja’s subsequent Malayalam albums did not feature Janaki. Nevertheless, it is a fait accompli that the IR-Janaki collaboration has yielded some of the finest moments of Malayalam film music; each song is an exquisite paradigm of perfection…. they are eternal mementos of the extraordinary empathy that existed between the composer and singer…

Image

* * * *

~ To be concluded in the next part ~


Tags: S.Janaki

S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part I : http://www.dhool.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=6791

S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part II : http://www.dhool.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=6831

S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part III : http://www.dhool.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=6858
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby tvsankar » Wed Dec 05, 2007 4:44 am

Dear Saravanan,
This time - your selections are excellent picks from top to bottom.

Ungal writitings ai padikaradha?? padalai ketpadha?? orae kuzhappam.

Adhanal, konjam ungal writings ,, konjam padalai ketpadhu enru

(Thaen kuditha Nari enru solvargalae , adhai pola) ungal writings ayum padalaiyum ketkiren....

Thank you for the Great Picks of SJ.

With Love,
Usha Sankar.
tvsankar
Centurion
 
Posts: 278
Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2005 9:59 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby OISG » Wed Dec 05, 2007 11:02 am

Listening to the first song...listening...again..again. hope to reach the 2 nd one tomorrow. Wonderful melody and sung soulful by SJ. I always loved her "Nishi" from Yakshaganam. I shall go back to "aayiram Jenmangal" write up and listen to the song again.

Saravanan, SJ must be fortunate to have a fan like you. Shall I put it "FM (no more just "TFM") must be fortunate to have a fan like you. Any idea about Bhojpuri movie songs :wink: With Mr.Sundar too providing vintage stuff , I wish BB and the dhool team get some deserved media coverage.

Oh!you are caught.Now you have to do the series on "MSV-in other languages." As we had once discussed "Lorry" was remade in Tamil as "rani"(?) with Pratap & Nithya, i believe. there is a superb SPB-SJ duet "Venil kala malargaLukkor vaazhaki vandhadhu,vaadai thendral engE vandhu vaazhthu sonnathu".
OISG
Silly Point
 
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:45 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Babu » Wed Dec 05, 2007 11:51 am

Thanks again Saravanan. I was hoping you would include Thumbi Vaa. I do not understand Malayalam, but this song has been on my music collection for a long time. I will never get enough of it. My 3-year old absolutely loves this song and sings the complete song without understanding a single word :) We have heard it so many times... thanks again.
Babu
Has hit a couple of fours
 
Posts: 22
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 11:22 am
Location: Eagan, MN

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby bb » Wed Dec 05, 2007 12:40 pm

Any idea about Bhojpuri movie songs


OISG, how did you guess? Saravanan is working on his next series, Nagma's songs in Bhojpuri. Videos included! :lol:
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby bb » Wed Dec 05, 2007 12:43 pm

I was hoping you would include Thumbi Vaa. I do not understand Malayalam, but this song has been on my music collection for a long time. I will never get enough of it. My 3-year old absolutely loves this song and sings the complete song without understanding a single word



Whenever I listen to Thumbi Vaa, I feel that the song is too fast. Slow it down, sing it in a more relaxed pace and the mood of the song is enhanced quite a bit.
bb
First Slip
 
Posts: 909
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2003 9:03 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby OISG » Wed Dec 05, 2007 1:07 pm

BB, :D
Sarvanan might choose John Clare poems to add colour to the rustic Bhojpuri lyrics. :wink:
OISG
Silly Point
 
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:45 am

Re: re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Babu » Wed Dec 05, 2007 1:12 pm

bb wrote:Whenever I listen to Thumbi Vaa, I feel that the song is too fast. Slow it down, sing it in a more relaxed pace and the mood of the song is enhanced quite a bit.


Will do. Does anyone know the meaning of this song?
Babu
Has hit a couple of fours
 
Posts: 22
Joined: Thu Oct 28, 2004 11:22 am
Location: Eagan, MN

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Wed Dec 05, 2007 9:03 pm

I am yet to listen to all the songs. Will comment once I am able to do so.
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Wed Dec 05, 2007 9:15 pm

Sara, that last picture, from the 70s, is a stunner!!
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Anniyan » Thu Dec 06, 2007 12:03 am

Saravanan,

Why MSV has not handled Hindolam this beautiful in tfm is the million dollar question now not to talk of his Unnidathil ennai…Malkauns. How is that when who had lost all his magic touch in a period in tfm, could produce such stunners in mfm! EnnadhAn irundhAlum, mother tongue pattru? Anyway, thank you .

Unfair Sara, our S-G in Mallu. Give us an opportunity to listen atleast one song of them.

IR’s Oru naal…KJY is no match to Balu, sorry. Thumbi vaa…your write-up for this song is equally nice!

Veene Veene… reminds me …with a whiff of fresh air… IR’s Kaatril endhan and Poopookkum maasam.

SJ songs apart, if you could give us an account of how IR was received in mfm with his totally different approach hitherto unheard of by the discerning mfm rasikas, will it not be interesting? Sorry for the trouble(?)

Too many songs, once again I have to listen.
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Saravanan » Thu Dec 06, 2007 12:27 am

Thank you all for the responses!

OISG, bb :D Btw, Ravi Kishan and Nagma may soon have to make way for Amitabh, Hemamalini and Preity Zinta, as they are all entering Bhojpuri cinema in a big way.

Babu, thumbi way is a great favourite of mine as well, what a song!

Btw, you can watch it here:

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=4fL-zqByB2E

Lokesh, I am sure you’ll enjoy the songs. And glad you liked the picture. Did you notice the other picture where Janaki and IR are jotting down V. Dakshinamoorthi’s notations?

Anniyan, what about 'manamE muruganin mayilvaahanam' the great Hindolam that MSV composed for (Radha) Jayalakshmi? In fact, whenever I listen to this Malayalam song, I link it to 'manamE muruganin'
Saravanan
The wind in the willows
 
Posts: 599
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:08 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Anniyan » Thu Dec 06, 2007 1:53 am

Saravanan,

Even I am reminded of Manamey muruganin...but I was talking about the period ...Manamey was way back in 60s. I can even quote Nalla manaivi nalla pillai, SG from Namma veettu Lakhsmi.

What about S-G?
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Anniyan » Thu Dec 06, 2007 9:58 am

Saravanan,

Oops, the song I mentioned earlier was 'yenpoove ponpoove' which reminded Kaatril and poopookkum and not 'veene veene'.

Of all the MSVs songs here, 'salanam jwalanam' ranks top. a fast paced still melodious song. With shades of Karaharapriya, I was very excited at one stage immediately when the interlude ended I jumped into 'sangeethapiriyan singaaravelan sandhangal paaduvaandi'. For a 1990 song, MSV is brilliant. I had the same feel of 'endhan karpanai thEril' which the master crafted more than a decade back.

The shehnai piece in 'veenapoovey' ....ada 'ninaikka therindha manamey...'

Swami-IR-SJ photograph - I really appreciate the pains taken by you in bringing a treasure to us. Rare and fantastic.

IR's Poovaadigalil - nice comparison to 'indha mandrathil odivarum' in the pallavi but IR remains IR throughout.
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Saravanan » Thu Dec 06, 2007 12:20 pm

Thank you again for the respone, Anniyan. And I am sorry that I don't have good quality tracks of S-G's songs Malayalam... am trying...

OISG, wasn't it VJ in vEnil kala malargaLukkor vaazhaki vandhadhu?
Saravanan
The wind in the willows
 
Posts: 599
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:08 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Sun Dec 09, 2007 3:11 am

Saravanan,

The first song, 'Veena Poove' is good one. My admiration for the 70s augmented by yet another 'unit.' The second one by MSV is the best one, according to my taste, in this episode. My admiration for MSV is grounded even more firmly.
The selection for IR songs, in my opinion, lacked the element of unfamiliarity and surprise. Selection of remakes did not help the cause. But then, perhaps, IR-Janaki combination in Malayalam might not have enough scope to let you choose HIDDEN gems.
I must say that I liked the selection of songs most in the Saleel Chaudhri/Oosha Khanna episode.
Last edited by Lokesh on Wed Jan 02, 2008 4:49 am, edited 3 times in total.
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Anniyan » Mon Dec 10, 2007 12:23 am

Dear Lokesh,

First of all, it is only SJ songs in MFM - how beautifully she sings the songs, the grasp and pronunciation of the language, that too, for one whose mother tongue is different. For the choice of songs, how can we expect a person born and brought up in Tamil nadu with an insatiable thirst for tfm, relatively very young in age, to know or have a complete knowledge in mfm. It is only with an intention, precisely put yaam pettra inbham peruga ivvaiyagam that our friend is bringing the songs he enjoyed, also with a scholarly write-up on each song. What is wrong in selecting remakes or how it did not help the cause, I fail to understand. In fact the remakes give us the additional joy of comparing the singing styles like KJY replacing SPB in Oru naal, for example.

If you like the selection in Salilda and Usha khanna it is because they had limited or no scope in tfm so that there are no parallels in mfm.

And this is not holding any brief for Sara as he is a favourite of everybody who visits here.
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Mon Dec 10, 2007 2:14 am

>he is a favourite of everybody who visits here.<

Surely, he is. It goes without saying. If he were not, why I would visit this site so frequently?
But a pleasant, sensitive, civil, friendly difference of opinion on song selection can never be taken as something very serious. It, in fact, rather serves to improve the quality of discussion, than the other way round.
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Anniyan » Mon Dec 10, 2007 9:06 am

Lokesh,

No no, nothing serious at all. What I thought on seeing your post I just shared with you as a friend.
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Tue Dec 11, 2007 1:22 am

Anniyan and Saravanan,
This I wanted to share with you.
I have, of late, listened to some of the sweetest duets by SJ from the 70s and the 80s in different tongues like Kannada and Telugu; some with SPB, and some with Rajkumar. I always had great esteem for those songs and it is only refreshed now. Still, I could not help marvelling that: How sweet, suave, silken and alluring Janaki is when she is in her mettle! How judicious she is in her emotions! How sensitive in her subtle touches! How alive she is to the general feel of the musical composition (song) wherein she performs! Really outstanding!
Last edited by Lokesh on Wed Dec 12, 2007 12:56 am, edited 2 times in total.
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Anniyan » Tue Dec 11, 2007 3:44 am

Lokesh,

So nice of you to have responded like this - SJ a highly gifted singer no doubt - PBS rates her to be a world-class singer whenever we discuss with him. Over to you Saravanan...
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Wed Dec 12, 2007 12:23 am

Here is one of those songs. One of the hundreds of masterpieces composed by the Pure Melody Makers, Rajan-Nagendra. It would be of no use to describe the beauty of this magical melody, and specially S. Jaanaki's performance in it; each moment is to be savoured with relish.

http://youtube.com/results?search_query ... =0&spell=1
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Saravanan » Wed Dec 12, 2007 3:00 am

Lokesh and Anniyan, my apologies for this belated response...have been tied up with work... will post the concluding part next week.

Anniyan, you are right.... in both my meetings with PBS as well he has expressed his awe for SJ..

Lokesh, thanks for that wonderful song! Btw, wasn't raaja nanna raaja by GKV? It had another Rajkumar/SJ duet as well 'kallethigintha ninna kanete'
Saravanan
The wind in the willows
 
Posts: 599
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:08 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Wed Dec 12, 2007 10:34 pm

Your apologies accepted, Sir. ;)

Well, Sara, the music and composition is so 'Rajan-Nagendresque' that I had no hesitation in categorising it as an R-N song. But now even I have started to harbour doubts!
Last edited by Lokesh on Thu Dec 13, 2007 5:15 am, edited 1 time in total.
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Thu Dec 13, 2007 5:10 am

You are right, Sara. It is indeed by GK Venkatesh. I was so taken up by the melody of this song that did not pay any attention to the tags!
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby OISG » Sat Dec 15, 2007 12:14 pm

Rajan Nagendra or GKV ...What next? SJ in Kannada?

this weekend i spent lisening to all the songs.Wonderful.Sorry to say that KJY hardly has done justice to the "Oru naaL".Well thats what happens when you have to sing an SPB song.

Thumbi vaa is a great composition.True,work can take back seat for a while:)

BTW ran thru NinaithalE inikkum for the nth time. Watching the US top ten in a channel and "Enchanted" was one of the top movies. I thought the copyright of the word is now with you:)
OISG
Silly Point
 
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:45 am

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Lokesh » Mon Dec 17, 2007 10:50 pm

Sara,
I am eagerly waiting (and waiting!) for the grand finale with, hopefully, some hidden gems by Shyam and other MD's.
Lokesh
Centurion
 
Posts: 131
Joined: Mon Nov 01, 2004 9:07 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Anniyan » Tue Dec 18, 2007 9:07 pm

Lokesh,

Pl wait for some more time. Perhaps Sara is taking time only to quench our thirst with hidden gems. I hope he is busy with P Bhanumathy series also simultaneously as PB's death anniversary is approaching. Anyway it is worth the wait.
Anniyan
Centurion
 
Posts: 288
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2005 9:45 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby vinatha » Fri Dec 21, 2007 11:47 am

Addicted to Veena poovey....!
Familiar raaja songs.
thanks, vinatha.
vinatha
Centurion
 
Posts: 335
Joined: Thu Oct 12, 2006 12:22 pm

re: SOTD #912: S.Janaki's songs in Malayalam - Part IV

Postby Saravanan » Sun Dec 23, 2007 7:57 pm

OISG and Vinatha, glad you enjoyed the songs!

Lokesh, I am sorry to keep you waiting. Continuing pressure at work coupled with recurring problems with my net connection and computer have effectively kept me out of the loop. Thankfully, things have eased off a bit now, and I will write the concluding part of this series soon.

Meanwhile, thanks to Anniyan for his reminder, I am writing the next part of the Bhanumati series to coincide with the anniversary of her passing away.
Saravanan
The wind in the willows
 
Posts: 599
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 1:08 am

Next

Return to Song Of The Day

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests